5 Famous Super Bowl Ads That Wouldn't Make It to Air Today

Super Bowl commercials are a cultural event, often talked about as much as the game itself. But as society changes, so does our sense of humor and what we find acceptable. Looking back, some of the most iconic ads from the past would likely cause a major controversy if they were released today.

1. General Motors: "Robot" (2007)

This ad from General Motors aimed to highlight the company’s commitment to quality by showing an assembly line robot being fired for dropping a screw. The commercial follows the dejected robot as it tries and fails at other jobs, ultimately leading to a scene where it imagines jumping off a bridge.

Why It Worked Then: At the time, the ad was seen by many as a quirky and dark-humored take on the pressures of perfection. The personification of the robot was intended to be a funny, exaggerated way to show how seriously GM took its manufacturing process. The commercial even won an award for its creativity.

Why It Wouldn’t Work Now: Today, conversations around mental health are much more prominent and sensitive. An ad that makes light of job loss, depression, and suicidal ideation, even with a non-human character, would be met with immediate and widespread criticism. Organizations like the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention spoke out against the ad even in 2007, but in the current climate, the backlash from social media would be immense. Brands are now expected to handle such topics with extreme care, if at all.

2. Snickers: "Mechanics" (2007)

In this well-known commercial, two auto mechanics are sharing a Snickers bar. As they eat from opposite ends, they accidentally meet in the middle for a brief kiss. Horrified, they both recoil and feel the need to prove their masculinity by violently ripping out their chest hair. The tagline was “You’re not you when you’re hungry.”

Why It Worked Then: The ad played on a type of “locker room” humor that was common in the 2000s. It used exaggerated stereotypes of masculinity for a comedic effect that resonated with a portion of the audience. The shock value of the accidental kiss was the central joke.

Why It Wouldn’t Work Now: This commercial would be widely condemned as homophobic. The premise that two men kissing is a moment of panic that must be “corrected” by a hyper-masculine act would be seen as offensive and harmful. LGBTQ+ advocacy groups and a large portion of the general public would call out the ad for promoting toxic masculinity and portraying affection between men as something to be ashamed of. Modern brands, like Doritos and Bud Light, now focus on themes of unity and inclusion in their Super Bowl spots.

3. SalesGenie: "Pandas" (2008)

This ad featured a family of pandas speaking with thick, stereotypical Chinese accents. They discuss the struggles of their furniture business until they discover the SalesGenie service, which helps them find new customers. The animation was simple, and the voice acting was the main feature.

Why It Worked Then: The ad’s creators likely thought they were being charming and memorable. In an era before social media was a dominant force for public accountability, ads could sometimes get away with humor that was tone-deaf or based on lazy stereotypes. The intention was likely not malicious, but its execution was poor.

Why It Wouldn’t Work Now: The ad would be immediately criticized for its use of racial stereotypes. Portraying a specific ethnic group through cartoon animals with exaggerated accents is a practice that is now widely understood to be offensive and demeaning. In today’s advertising landscape, where diversity and authentic representation are highly valued, this commercial would be a textbook example of what not to do. The backlash would be swift, leading to public apologies and potentially damaging the brand’s reputation permanently.

4. Dodge Charger: "Man's Last Stand" (2010)

This commercial presented a montage of men staring into the camera, seemingly speaking to their partners. They list all the things they will sacrifice for the relationship, such as listening to chick-flicks, pretending to be interested in shoes, and even putting the toilet seat down. The punchline is that driving a powerful Dodge Charger is the one “manly” thing they refuse to give up.

Why It Worked Then: The ad tapped into traditional, stereotypical gender roles that were still common comedic fodder in advertising. It was meant to be a relatable “battle of the sexes” joke, where men felt their masculinity was being compromised by domestic life.

Why It Wouldn’t Work Now: The commercial relies heavily on outdated and sexist tropes. It portrays women as nagging partners who force men to abandon their interests, and it frames relationships as a zero-sum game of compromise rather than a partnership. In an era that values gender equality, this ad would be criticized for promoting harmful stereotypes about both men and women. Modern car ads are more likely to feature capable, independent women or focus on family, adventure, and technology rather than gender-based complaints.

5. Just for Feet: "Kenya" (1999)

Considered by many to be one of the most disastrous Super Bowl ads of all time, this commercial showed a group of white men in a Humvee tracking a barefoot Black Kenyan runner through the savanna. They knock him out with a tranquilizer, and when he wakes up, he finds they have forced a pair of Nike sneakers onto his feet. He then screams and tries to run away, but the shoes are holding him back.

Why It Worked Then: The baffling thing is that it didn’t really “work” even then. The ad was immediately and fiercely criticized. The company, Just for Feet, claimed the ad was meant to be a humorous take on their commitment to helping athletes everywhere. However, the imagery was so poorly conceived that this message was completely lost.

Why It Wouldn’t Work Now: This ad is a masterclass in offensive content. Its imagery evokes themes of colonialism, white saviors, and non-consensual acts. The depiction of tracking and subduing a Black man is deeply disturbing and racially insensitive. Today, this ad would not make it past the first round of internal review. If it somehow did, the public outcry would be catastrophic, leading to immediate boycotts and a public relations crisis that could destroy a company. It serves as a powerful reminder of how disconnected an advertiser can be from cultural reality.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are Super Bowl ads so expensive? Brands pay a premium for Super Bowl ad slots because of the massive, captive audience. It is one of the few televised events where millions of people actively watch the commercials, providing unparalleled exposure. For 2024, a 30-second spot reportedly cost around $7 million.

How has Super Bowl advertising changed over the years? The biggest change is the shift from broad, often edgy humor to more inclusive and purpose-driven messaging. Early ads often relied on slapstick, shock value, and stereotypes. Today’s ads are more likely to feature emotional storytelling, celebrity cameos, and messages that align with social values like diversity, sustainability, and community. The rise of social media also means every ad is instantly scrutinized by millions, forcing brands to be much more careful.

Are there still controversial Super Bowl ads today? Yes, but the nature of the controversy has changed. Modern controversies are less likely to stem from overtly offensive content and more often from ads being perceived as politically divisive, tone-deaf, or manipulative. For example, a 2017 ad from 84 Lumber that touched on the topic of immigration sparked significant debate. Brands walk a fine line trying to be memorable without alienating a portion of the massive audience.